CALL Business Meeting Summary – September 2026

At Wildfire.

  • Open Meeting (Todd) 12:00 p.m.
    • Introduction & welcome statement
    • Number of attendees – 59 registered
    • New members:
      • Allison De Weerd
      • Amy Lin
      • Christian Miller (in attendance)
      • Holly Muskat (in attendance)
      • Paul Riermaier
      • Samuel Schlegel
      • Charlotte Stretch
      • Chris Welles (in attendance)
      • Stephen Wesclitz
      • Justine Withers (in attendance)
    • Thank sponsor: Thomson Reuters
  • Sponsor speak (Blythe McCoy) 12:10 p.m.
  • Introduce speaker (Diana) 12:10 p.m.
    • Jacob Nadal, President of the Center for Research Libraries
      • Library and archival preservation Center for Research Libraries
      • Director of Preservation at Library of Congress previously and many others
      • CRL background: contribute to preservation and sharing of knowledge in partnership with members with a global orientation where we always think about stewardship, always find ways to build communities and increase access. We are not just collecting we are thinking about sustainability.
      • CRL, 1949. Global and niche collection, a collection of first resort and a collection of last resort – responsible deaccession support. CRL good for historical, international legal research. Documentary record of government.
        • Foreign official gazettes
        • Early US State legal documents – microfilm and some print
        • Colonial and post-colonial legal documents – e.g. Indonesian collection
        • Courts, trials and international law. (military tribunals, etc.)
        • Law in practice – ministry reports, budgets, etc.
        • Newspapers and the public record – international news
        • Licensing of digital resources available too
      • Licensing of digital resources available too.
      • Upcoming:
        • Cataloging and Ready for climate change and cybersecurity
        • Grappling with AI – exciting, humbling and exhausting. What are the preservation considerations around AI?
          • AI cannot preserve the original record or provenance
          • Independent stewards of the record and materials and being able to verify
          • Preservation: people care about things by interreacting with them (listening to a recording, reading, etc.)
          • Absent the libraries and CRL we cannot achieve preservation – need an institution to organize and share.
          • AI cannot maintain and validate a record. AI cannot span the rift of preservation
          • And then – how do you pay for it?
          • Commercial value built on the premise that AI can provide accurate information. But requires verification.
          • Be deliberate – We need to build the structures to be a coalition with roles and responsibilities to validate.
          • Wants to hear how we are thinking about Ai and how to approach.
          • Visit CRL.edu – strategic framework.
          • Commercial valuation built on work that our profession will do without any compensation for this work. See article.
          • Confident librarians will have a meaningful contribution to the changes coming with the technology and AI
          • Welcome us as members and we want the community to be part of the conversation. Who is a member is less important than who has ideas and can contribute.
          • Issue paper: Press Release: Issues and Model Terms for Libraries and Their Partners | Center for Research Libraries
        • Questions
          • Prominence of AI –  are the resources to check and validate at risk of being unavailable? How do we handle tis unfunded mandate? It’s not in the interest of commercial firms to do that but it is in the interest of society to do this.
          • Collections like CRLs – would they be licensed to LLMs so the quality is better. We know our resources have already been used. Bot traffic from China is so significant  – had to turn off traffic to China. We’ve seen it from all commercial players taking advantage of open access. This was not the intent behind open access and we are seeing a re-set of this. Our statement came about when CRL was approached with an offer to pay for resources – it was for mining and not partnership. Need terms that are with partnership. And don’t want to give any one player single access and no shared material.
          • The agentic tools need something to be able to properly reflect and analyze.
          • Still plenty that is exclusively analog.
          • How much work is in digitization is re-digitization due to poorer quality. There is some. CRL is one of the paper copies of JSTOR. Constantly gap filling and pulling from that collection every week.
          • What, in an ideal world, is your AI regulation? I would look for – as things are brought across the divide. There needs to be something to ensure its stewardship. There needs to be some monetary valuation of the stewardship. It’s not a commodity and once it is digital it is a commodity. The value is built on the artifact and the preservation needs to be subsidized. And, careful management of access and embargo. Protect the commercial incentive without imperiling overall access. And how the provenance is embedded or even transparency – this corpus of info is built on this resource in this collection.
          • Archiving of web and government data – no, but ask me again tomorrow. If we got into that we might distract from others who have been doing this for a while and have a sophisticated system. But we are looking at a safe harbor program – CRL may not need to be the final collector of the info from a closing university, etc. BUT we could hold a body of content for a period of time and BUY the owner of the content enough time to make a decision on the materials and web based materials.
          • AI scanning used books – 80/20 – 80, okay that was inevitable; 20 – not a real loss, the amount of books produced far outstrips the amount of books that will be bought, loved and owned. However, it is likely that there are still some scarce materials that have been disbound and shred. Need to watch the sentiment analysis – we can’t let community sentiment be the sole driver but we do need to consider it. Especially for preservation, sentiment runs hot as it pertains to AI.
    • Thanks to Sheri Lewis for the speaker recommendation.
  • Thank speaker (Diana) 12:40 p.m.
  • Committee announcements 12:40-12:45 p.m. (Todd)
    • Continuing Ed (Bob Winger) *upcoming virtual roundtable program (likely Oct 15th at noon) “What your law students and new associates need to know about legal research”
    • Diversity & Inclusion (Kristen) *announcement re: forthcoming survey to help determine next steps to serve CALL well
    • Mentorship & Career Development (Carrie) *fall happy hour on Tuesday October 13th at 320 S Canal
    • Nominations & Elections (Philip) *plug for candidates. There is still time for nominations. Ask Philip if you have questions.
    • e. Public relations (Matt) *PR update (revamping social media policy – and if anyone is interested in joining the committee to help, you will see draft for providing feedback at the beginning of the year.
  • Awards 12:45-12:55 p.m. (Todd)
    • The Agnes and Harvey Reid Award for Outstanding Contribution to Law Librarianship: Matt Timko, introduced by Philip Johnson
  • Door prize drawings (Blythe – gift cards) (Scott) 12:55-1:00 pm
    • Carrie Port
    • Ariel Scotese
  • Adjourn meeting (Todd) 1:00 p.m.

,